Between 1835 and 1848 Liebig, Fehling and Weidenbusch recorded crystals and liquids forming from aldehyde in storage and under acid, without yet using the name paraldehyde.
Reading Library · Anesthesia Epochs · 中文版
Watch the education video (for clinicians)
1835–1848: Liebig and Fehling — Changes in the Aldehyde Bottle · Anesthesia Epochs Education Series

In his 1838 report, Fehling described numerous transparent, ice-like crystals in a small bottle of Aldehyd that had stood for several weeks during the previous severe winter. With slight warming, most melted; a small portion remained. In 1838 he placed this observation at the beginning of a four-page report.[2, p. 319]
Within one bottle, apparently similar material behaved differently. Keeping those differences visible is the first step in reading this history. A familiar later sedative name, paraldehyde, cannot by itself identify every substance in the earlier accounts.
1835: crystals appeared, but the conditions remained unclear
In a paper published three years earlier, Liebig had described long, transparent crystals developing in stored Aldehyd. He admitted that he did not know the conditions responsible. An initial explanation involving oxygen was unsettled by another observation: five of six sealed tubes remained unchanged, while crystals appeared in just one.[1, pp. 141–142]
He recorded another distinction that a compressed timeline could easily lose. Apart from the crystals, the remaining Aldehyd contained a less volatile liquid resembling Acetal.[1, p. 142] The crystals and residual liquid were separate observations. They cannot be merged into the statement that he had obtained pure paraldehyde.
The paper begins with an earlier comparison of materials. Liebig says that Döbereiner had sent him specimens; comparison allowed him to distinguish their components and describe the substance he called Aldehyd.[1, pp. 133–134] This is the author's account of his investigation, not a basis here for adjudicating worldwide discovery priority.

1838: two materials, with unequal opportunities for analysis
Fehling did not treat all the crystals in his bottle as a single object. For the small portion that remained after slight warming, he explicitly cited Liebig's account in volume 14, page 141, identifying a connection between them. The link is printed in the original report.[2, p. 319]
There was too little of this material for every planned check. He performed a composition analysis but could not measure its vapor density to check the result. On another occasion he left crystals in their container, hoping that more would form. Several weeks later they had disappeared entirely.[2, pp. 319–320] Waiting for a larger sample had not guaranteed more evidence.
Fehling described the readily melting portion separately. For this material he reported both composition analyses and a vapor-density determination. His calculation led him to propose that three volumes of Aldehyd had condensed into one.[2, pp. 320–322] That is the author's historical interpretation. This article does not recast his old notation as a settled modern molecular structure or adopt his recorded physical values as present-day identification standards.
The title describes two compounds isomeric with Aldehyd. The two materials did not receive equal analytical support, and their conditions of formation remained incompletely understood.

1848: one acid, two directions
Ten years later, Weidenbusch encountered different products again while investigating the action of acids and alkalis on Aldehyd. He states that the work was conducted in Liebig's laboratory with Liebig's assistance.[3, p. 152]
In the section on sulfuric and nitric acids, needle-shaped crystals and the overlying liquid are discussed separately. There were too few crystals for analysis. From their behavior and a comparison with Liebig's account in volume 14, page 141, Weidenbusch assigned them to Metaldehyd. He subjected the liquid to separate composition analyses and a vapor-density determination.[3, pp. 155–157] Adjacent descriptions do not make these two materials a single, subsequently familiar medicine.
Weidenbusch also explicitly cites Fehling's report in volume 27, page 321. He finds a striking resemblance but claims differences in chemical behavior. He acknowledges that he had not prepared Fehling's material himself for comparison.[3, p. 157] The passage establishes a documented connection between the investigations while preserving the author's own limit on that comparison.
It also records a further observation. According to Weidenbusch, the same acid promoted formation of the new product at a lower temperature and converted it back to Aldehyd at a higher temperature. The acid remained present and, he considered, unchanged; he interpreted its action as dynamic or catalytic.[3, pp. 155, 157] This is an account of his observation and explanation in 1848, not a claim that a modern molecular structure or reaction mechanism had been established.
The paper subsequently turns to sulfur-containing products and their analysis. Those passages cannot be reassigned to the liquid described above, and the paper reports no clinical use.[3, pp. 158–165] It extends the history of changing materials without turning a chemical observation into an anesthetic or sedative method.
A later name cannot complete an earlier identification
Neither Paraldehyd nor Metaldehyd appears in Fehling's complete four-page paper. This article therefore does not present the report as a naming with those terms, or attach the later sedative's identity directly to the crystals described in 1835.[2, pp. 319–322]
Weidenbusch's complete 1848 paper likewise does not use the name Paraldehyd. That is distinct from his use of Metaldehyd on page 156.[3, pp. 152–165] So 1848 cannot be treated as a verified year of naming paraldehyde. Later adoption of the term and the correspondence between the earlier materials and modern substances require their own evidence.
There is a specific connection to the earlier Liebig chloral article: the 1835 paper mentions Chloral while comparing properties.[1, pp. 139–140] Both belong to the author's investigation of materials and their changes. This connection establishes neither a shared clinical action nor a treatment report in these chemical investigations.

Across 1835–1848, the records move from changes in storage to transformations in opposite directions under different conditions. Investigators distinguished products and compared earlier reports while acknowledging scarce samples and comparisons they had not performed. Later names and clinical uses still require evidence from their own periods.
Sources and reading limits
- Justus Liebig. Ueber die Producte der Oxydation des Alkohols. Annalen der Pharmacie. 1835;14:133–167. Read: pp. 133–134, 139–142 and the last page, p. 167; the rest of the paper is not covered. The year 1835 follows the library catalogue record.
- H. Fehling. Ueber zwei dem Aldehyd isomere Verbindungen. Annalen der Pharmacie. 1838;27:319–322. Read in full, with the volume title page (Austrian National Library copy).
- Weidenbusch. Ueber einige Producte der Einwirkung von Alkalien und Säuren auf den Aldehyd. Annalen der Chemie und Pharmacie. 1848;66:152–165. Read in full, with the volume title page. The absence of the name Paraldehyd here does not settle when the name was first used.
This article covers the 1835, 1838 and 1848 reports. An 1829 date, the later naming of paraldehyde and modern identification are not settled here; the clinical reports of 1869 and 1882–1883 are outside its scope. All four images are AI-made illustrations.
Continue exploring
Related reading connects shared questions and contexts; it does not by itself establish historical influence.
- 1832: Liebig's Observations and Questions on Chloral
- 1882–1883: Cervello's Paraldehyde, Between Sleep and Surgery
Anesthesia Epochs · The Source Room · About & Editorial Method
Updated October 30, 2026. Sources and reading limits are stated above. Illustrations are labelled as original source images or AI-made. Historical accounts are educational; they are not current treatment instructions.