In July 1891 the Dental and Surgical Microcosm, edited by Samuel J. Hayes in Pittsburgh, began as a quarterly devoted chiefly to anaesthesia at one dollar a year, and in 1892 its first two volumes were bound together as one.
Reading Library · Anesthesia Epochs · 中文版
Watch the education video (for clinicians)
1891: The Dental and Surgical Microcosm — A Journal Announces Itself · Anesthesia Epochs Education Series
One dollar a year, or thirty cents a copy. A subscription notice in the 1891 Dental and Surgical Microcosm made its prices prominent and promised quarterly publication. The journal sought a place in physicians’ and dentists’ libraries, chiefly addressing anaesthesia and its relationship with surgery. [1, p. 72]
Here was a journal looking for readers. Prices, a publication schedule, invitations to contribute and requests for exchanges show something of the work behind sustained discussion: a lecture or an article needed people willing to keep reading.

An 1891 first issue inside an 1892 volume
The surviving scan carries two dates that are easy to confuse. The first issue is headed Volume I, July 1891, Number 1. The combined title page gives 1892 and identifies the contents as Volumes I and II. [1, p. 1; title page]
The preface explains the arrangement. Signed by the controlling editor at Pittsburgh in October 1892, it says that the first volume began in July 1891 and the second would be incomplete at the close of 1892. The two were to be bound together, with Volume III beginning in January 1893 and following the calendar year. [1, preface]
The title page names Samuel J. Hayes as controlling editor and Frederick Gaertner as assistant editor. Its publisher is the Hayes Dental and Surgical Manufacturing Co., at 804 Penn Avenue, Pittsburgh. [1, title page]
Keeping the qualification attached
The opening editorial described this as the only journal chiefly devoted to anaesthesia, anaesthetics and their cooperative relationship with surgery—but qualified that claim by the editors’ knowledge. The 1892 preface likewise qualified its claim to being first and alone. [1, p. 49; preface]
These statements establish how the editors presented their venture. They do not independently settle the priority of every journal worldwide. The editorial also promised open discussion, invited informed contributions and said that error should be challenged even when supported by prestigious names. [1, pp. 49–50]
Those were editorial aims. They do not document how every later submission was assessed or establish a modern system of peer review. Both the named publishing company and the journal’s stated position belong in the record.
An older paper in a new journal
The opening article is by S. A. Waterman of New York and concerns the effects of anaesthetics as examined through spectroscopic observations. Its first page says that an ideal anaesthetic remains unavailable and that existing agents carry dangers. [1, p. 1]
A footnote on that same page dates the presentation to 16 August 1877. Its appearance in the 1891 first issue does not make it a newly completed 1891 experiment.
The editorial review on pages 50–51 urges readers to study Waterman’s article alongside the editor’s own “The Science of Anaesthesia,” beginning on page 14. The editor praises their agreement and guides the reader through the issue. [1, pp. 50–51] This documents editorial selection and interpretation, not independent experimental confirmation.
Making readers return
The journal sought consecutive subscriptions as well as contributions. Page 51 encourages readers to retain complete volumes for reference, asks other publishers to add it to their exchange lists and advises medical and dental associations and schools to request the editor’s lectures well in advance. [1, p. 51]
Reading, keeping, exchanging and speaking meet in these notices. They reveal a proposed means of circulation, without supplying actual sales, completed exchanges or attendance figures. The preface speaks of an unprecedented subscription without giving figures. [1, preface]
The notice on page 72 specifies the first of July, October, January and April and gives the annual and single-copy prices. These are advertised dates and rates, not a record of each issue’s dispatch or receipts. [1, p. 72]
Reading beside a 1922 clinical article
Frances E. Haines’s 1922 article on anaesthesia in children appeared in a later journal of the specialty. Its first page is dated October 1922, names methods and agents in its title and frames safety as relative. [2, p. 50] The first page of Seldon’s 1971 journal history dates Volume I, Number 1 of Anesthesia and Analgesia to August 1922. [3, p. 571]
The materials can be read beside one another. Microcosm’s 1891–1892 records show editors organizing a journal around anaesthesia; Haines supplies a particular clinical discussion in a 1922 journal. Their chronological distance does not by itself establish direct institutional or intellectual descent.
A first editorial preserves promises about the future. Keeping those promises distinct from the material already printed, and from later outcomes still to be examined, allows the declaration to remain evidence without making it stand for an entire publishing history.
Sources and reading limits
Read: in the University of Toronto Dentistry copy on Internet Archive, the combined title page of Volumes I and II, the complete preface, the opening page of the first article, printed pages 49–51 with the salutatory, the editorial review and notices, and the subscription notice on page 72; page 50 of Haines’s 1922 article; and page 571 of Seldon’s 1971 history. [1–3]
Not covered: the rest of the first issue and of the run, including the editor’s article beginning on page 14 and the remainder of Waterman’s paper; the later publication history, circulation figures and any review process; global priority among journals; and the technical priority of the Hayes inhaler.
- The Dental and Surgical Microcosm. Vol. I, No. 1, July 1891; combined title of Volumes I–II dated 1892, preface dated October 1892. Digitized original.
- Haines FE. Anesthesia in Children: Safest Methods and Agents. 1922;1(2):50–54,70. DOI: 10.1213/00000539-192210000-00003. Original page 50.
- Seldon TH. Anesthesia and Analgesia—50 Years of Publication. Anesth Analg. 1971;50(4):571–577. Article scan.
Continue exploring
Related reading connects shared questions and contexts; it does not by itself establish historical influence.
Anesthesia Epochs · The Source Room · About & Editorial Method
Updated October 30, 2026. Sources and reading limits are stated above. Illustrations are labelled as original source images or AI-made. Historical accounts are educational; they are not current treatment instructions.
