Between 1889 and 1891 four children with tubercular meningitis at the Middlesex Hospital had cerebrospinal fluid drained to relieve pressure; some improved briefly, all four died, and W. Essex Wynter reported the cases in The Lancet in May 1891.
Reading Library · Anesthesia Epochs · 中文版
Watch the education video (for clinicians)
1891: Wynter's Spinal Drainage — Four Cases, Read to the End · Anesthesia Epochs Education Series
The breathing became regular, the colour improved, and the child swallowed some milk. W. Essex Wynter recorded these changes after an attempt to drain cerebrospinal fluid and relieve pressure. What followed was not recovery. Drainage stopped, the improvement did not last, and the child died. [1, p. 981]
Stopping halfway through that account would produce a story of technical success. Reading to the end leaves a harder question: how much does a temporary change establish?
Four cases, across more than one year
Wynter's report appeared on pages 981–982 of The Lancet dated 2 May 1891. The byline identifies Wynter as medical registrar at the Middlesex Hospital. Its title and introduction state the therapeutic purpose: continuous drainage through a spinal route to relieve fluid pressure that Wynter believed contributed to coma. [1, p. 981]
The first case was a three-year-old boy treated in February 1889. The second child's admission, operation and death occurred in February 1890; the fourth case was in April 1891. The third account gives June dates without explicitly stating a year in that paragraph. [1, pp. 981–982]
Access was not the same in every case
The first child was already comatose, with deteriorating breathing. After consultation, an attempt was made to relieve pressure. Wynter states that no anaesthetic was needed and describes a small skin incision, a Southey tube and trocar, followed by drainage through fine rubber tubing. Wynter does not describe removal of a vertebral lamina in this case. [1, p. 981]
The second intervention was different. An eleven-year-old girl was admitted under Cayley on 12 February 1890. On 21 February, Hulke used an open approach involving removal of bone before establishing drainage. The next day the temperature fell; the child could be roused and took liquid food. As drainage diminished, drowsiness increased. The child died in coma on 25 February. At necropsy, the opening was found closed, with fluid retained inside. [1, p. 981]
The third child, a boy aged two years and four months, was admitted under Coupland. Pearce Gould performed open exposure and drainage on 21 June. Wynter described an immediate response: previously dilated, unresponsive pupils contracted and regained their reaction when fluid escaped. The child nevertheless died five hours after the operation. [1, p. 981]

Improvement and outcome
The fourth patient was a thirteen-month-old girl admitted on 13 April 1891. Drainage with a Southey tube was performed on 15 April. The account records bloodstaining in the later fluid, a sinking fontanelle and death that afternoon. Necropsy showed general tuberculosis, especially marked in the lungs. [1, pp. 981–982]
All four children died. Wynter's closing observation was that some had temporary relief; it does not say that all four improved. [1, p. 982]
Wynter nevertheless judged that the interventions had caused no harm. Wynter attributed the fatal outcomes to extensive tuberculosis or failure to maintain drainage, particularly regretting closure of the opening in the second case and the renewed accumulation of fluid. [1, p. 982] These are the author's interpretations of the observations and necropsy findings. An uncontrolled series of four fatal cases cannot by itself establish procedural safety, nor show that maintaining drainage would have secured survival.
The report places observations and expectations close together: changes in breathing, swallowing, pupils and fluid escape, followed by hope that better case selection and more effective drainage would improve treatment. That hope is not a subsequent outcome.
Beside spinal anaesthesia, with a different purpose
In 1899 Bier opened a paper on spinal anaesthesia by naming Quincke’s lumbar puncture and describing the injection of cocaine to make large areas of the body insensitive to pain; Bier’s first case is dated 16 August 1898. [2, pp. 361–362]
Reading the two papers together clarifies a specific distinction. Wynter's report concerns removing fluid in an attempt to relieve pressure. Bier's concerns administering a drug for surgical analgesia. Both involve access to cerebrospinal fluid, but chronology alone does not make them one invention or establish direct influence from Wynter to Bier.
Sources and reading limits
Read: the complete Wynter article in The Lancet, 1891, volume I, pp. 981–982, on the page images of a digitized copy of the volume on Internet Archive; and pp. 361–362 of Bier’s 1899 paper. [1–2]
Not covered: the rest of the Lancet volume and the original patient records; the remaining pages of Bier’s paper; Quincke’s own work and questions of priority; the safety or effectiveness of drainage. Wynter’s four cases are one author’s report, not four independent studies, and the diagnosis of tubercular meningitis follows that report; it has not been confirmed independently for each child.
- Wynter WE. Four cases of tubercular meningitis in which paracentesis of the theca vertebralis was performed for the relief of fluid pressure. Lancet. 2 May 1891;I:981–982. DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(02)16784-5. Digitized volume and article pages.
- Bier A. Versuche über Cocainisirung des Rückenmarkes. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Chirurgie. 1899;51:361–369. DOI: 10.1007/BF02792160. Zenodo.
Continue exploring
Related reading connects shared questions and contexts; it does not by itself establish historical influence.
Anesthesia Epochs · The Source Room · About & Editorial Method
Updated October 30, 2026. Sources and reading limits are stated above. Illustrations are labelled as original source images or AI-made. Historical accounts are educational; they are not current treatment instructions.
