In 1842 Erichsen tied the coronary vessels in dogs and rabbits and found the ventricles soon stopped, leaving only a slight trembling while the auricles went on.
Reading Library · Anesthesia Epochs · 中文版
Watch the education video (for clinicians)
1842: Erichsen's Coronary Study — How the Heart Still Moved · Anesthesia Epochs Education Series

Twenty-one minutes after the vessels were tied, ventricular action had ceased except for a slight trembling motion. The auricles continued to act. John E. Erichsen recorded this distinction in the first animal experiment of his 1842 report.[1, p. 561]
“The heart was still moving” requires closer description here. Which part moved, what kind of movement remained, and for how long? Compressing those observations into a later diagnostic name would lose some of what the investigator actually recorded.
A question about the heart’s blood supply
Erichsen wanted to determine how arresting the coronary circulation affected cardiac action. He began with the relationship between blood supply and contractility in voluntary muscle, then turned to the heart. He explicitly cited Marshall Hall’s lectures of that year, which connected certain sudden deaths with interruption of the coronary circulation, as a reason to investigate experimentally.[1, p. 561]
Hall appears here as a source Erichsen invoked in his own paper. Hall’s original lecture text is not covered here, and no conversation between the men at an experimental scene is reconstructed.
Two dates can be distinguished. A footnote on page 561 says that the paper was read at the British Association for the Advancement of Science on 24 June 1842. The issue heading gives 8 July. This article uses the latter, the publication date, for its place on the timeline. Neither date automatically dates each experiment.[1, p. 561 footnote and issue heading]

An average that excluded one result
The first series lists seven experiments involving two dogs and five rabbits. Erichsen observed their hearts under conditions following lethal experimental preparation, with artificial respiration used to maintain the experimental setting. He recorded time both after what he called the animal’s death and after coronary ligation. Those are the report’s time origins, not present-day clinical determinations of death.[1, pp. 561–562]
The results varied. Ventricular action in the first dog ceased twenty-one minutes after ligation; in the second, it ceased after only three. The other records also differed.[1, pp. 561–562] Erichsen considered the second result so discrepant that some source of error must have entered the experiment, and excluded it from his average. For the remaining experiments, he reported a mean duration of ventricular action after ligation of twenty-three and a half minutes.[1, p. 562]
That number carries a choice made by the author. Reporting only the average would conceal both the excluded observation and his reason for excluding it. The paper supplied no modern randomized controlled design for these results.
What happened to the accompanying veins
Erichsen also identified a problem within the experimental conditions. Working with such small vessels, he said, often meant including the accompanying vein in the ligature. This altered not only blood entering the myocardium but the conditions under which it could leave.[1, pp. 562–563]
He then changed the state of retained venous blood and reported earlier cessation of regular ventricular action, with slight trembling continuing and auricular activity lasting longer.[1, p. 563] This part of the argument brings observation and explanation together: what he saw, which condition he thought accounted for the difference, and a further experiment directed at that question.
The paper subsequently discusses another condition affecting the distribution of blood within the heart and records the order in which the right and left auricles and ventricles ceased to act.[1, pp. 563–564] This article preserves those distinctions without treating every local movement as a complete heartbeat.

The author’s interpretation
Erichsen ended with two conclusions: arrest of the coronary circulation caused cardiac action to cease relatively quickly, while increasing blood sent into or retained within the heart’s muscular tissue increased its activity. He then considered how these results might bear on death in certain cardiac diseases.[1, p. 564]
These were the author’s interpretations and extrapolations from his animal experiments. The paper reports no human treatment trial and no electrical reversal. This article preserves the observed trembling without supplying an imagined modern rhythm recording or using these four pages to adjudicate a worldwide “first ventricular fibrillation.”
A passage in Kite’s 1788 book provides a useful comparison. Kite recalled repeated muscular contractions in a drowned young man, followed by the disappearance of the response, without recording recovery.[2, pp. 123–124] Erichsen distinguished activity in separate parts of the heart under experimental conditions. Movement has a specific meaning in each account, with limits to what it establishes about the outcome. This is a comparison between texts, not evidence of direct influence between their authors.

The detail worth retaining in this 1842 report lies in differences of timing, location and experimental conditions. It allows a reader to follow an investigator framing a question, handling inconsistent results and setting out the explanations he considered possible.
Sources and reading limits
- John E. Erichsen. On the Influence of the Coronary Circulation on the Action of the Heart. London Medical Gazette. 1842; New Series II (overall volume XXX):561–564. Published 8 July; the footnote records a reading on 24 June. Read in full, with the volume title page and the issue heading. Another article begins in the right column of page 564; the range 561–583 in some later citations is not adopted.
- Charles Kite. An Essay on the Recovery of the Apparently Dead. London: C. Dilly; 1788. Pages 123–124 are cited.
This article concerns the 1842 report. Worldwide priority and correspondence with a modern diagnosis remain unadjudicated. Material dated 1775 is not verified here; material dated 1849, 1899 and 1930 is outside this account’s scope. All four illustrations are original historical imaginings or modern conceptual images.
Continue exploring
Related reading connects shared questions and contexts; it does not by itself establish historical influence.
- 1788: Kite's Essay on Resuscitation and a Body That Moved
- 1914: Goodman Levy Blames Ventricular Fibrillation for Light Chloroform Deaths
Anesthesia Epochs · The Source Room · About & Editorial Method
Updated October 30, 2026. Sources and reading limits are stated above. Illustrations are labelled as original source images or AI-made. Historical accounts are educational; they are not current treatment instructions.