In September 1847 ether was tried in Wellington on a prisoner's tooth and on the chief Hiangarere's shoulder tumour; its effect wore off after the third incision.
Reading Library · Anesthesia Epochs · 中文版
Watch the education video (for clinicians)
1847: Ether in Wellington — After the Third Incision · Anesthesia Epochs Education Series

After the third incision, the patient quickly recovered from ether's influence, and ether was not applied again. That is the sequence recorded in a Wellington newspaper on 29 September 1847.[1]
The chief from Waikanae was unnamed in that report. A doctor's report and a letter published a few months later give him a name and a subsequent history: Hiangarere had undergone removal of a tumour from his shoulder and back, and the letter reported that the wound had healed.[2, pp32–33 and inpatient return]
Read together, these records allow the patient to remain in view after the day of surgery. They also prevent later wound healing from becoming evidence that the entire operation had been painless.
A tooth in the gaol
According to the newspaper, Dr Fitzgerald, Dr Monteith and Mr Marriott, who had constructed the inhaling apparatus, first went to the gaol. An unnamed prisoner wanted a tooth extracted. Inhalation initially produced no effect. Marriott altered the instrument, after which the patient entered what the report called a state of insensibility.[1]
The tooth then presented another difficulty. It was decayed, and a side gave way under the forceps. Ether's effect immediately wore off. Fitzgerald said that, had the tooth not broken, or had the instrument fitted properly, it could have been removed without pain.[1]
That was a conditional judgement about what might have happened. The original account did not document a completed, uncomplicated, painless extraction. Its details preserve the need to adjust an inhaler, the difficulty of applying an instrument and the limits of a brief period of insensibility.
Marriott made, adjusted and applied the inhaling apparatus. Modern institutional accounts identify James Marriott as an optician and instrument maker. The contemporary report calls him “Mr,” distinguishing him from the two doctors.[1,3–4]

The operation at the hospital
The other procedure took place that day at the institution the newspaper called the Native Hospital. Fitzgerald operated with Monteith's assistance; Marriott applied the inhaling apparatus. Several people from Pipitea pā were present. The patient's tumour extended from the top of the left shoulder across the back towards the right shoulder blade and weighed about three pounds.[1]
The initial ether effect allowed the operation to begin. The report then specifically describes recovery after the third incision and says that ether was not reapplied. It supplies neither a full duration of anaesthesia nor the patient's direct account of pain throughout the procedure.[1]
Removal of the tumour and a wholly painless operation are different claims. The Geoffrey Kaye Museum's modern summary describes painless removal; this article retains the more detailed contemporary sequence.[3] Equally, recovery from ether does not entitle us to supply the patient's unrecorded words or quantify the pain he experienced.
The newspaper says that he was anxious to return home and that preparations were complete, so the operation was not delayed to await other medical men. That explains the reason the report gives for proceeding. It does not reconstruct an unrecorded discussion of consent.[1]
A name and news from home
Fitzgerald's hospital report, dated 21 January 1848, identifies Hiangarere as the patient from Waikanae who received ether before removal of a shoulder-back tumour. The accompanying inpatient return names him, records a tumour of about three pounds and places 7 December in the column for discharge as cured.[2, p32 and inpatient return]
A letter dated 15 December 1847 appears with Māori text and a contemporary English translation printed alongside it. The signatures are Wiremu Tamihana in the Māori text and William Thompson in English. Fitzgerald identifies the writer as Hiangarere's son. The printed translation reports that Hiangarere had returned to Waikanae, that his wound had healed and that he had spoken of the doctor's attention.[2, pp32–33]
This provides a more specific account of recovery than the day's newspaper report alone. It remains a family letter incorporated into a doctor's report, read here through its historical printed translation. It is neither a clinical record written by the patient nor a new independent translation of the Māori manuscript. It does not establish a long-term tumour outcome or continuous freedom from pain during surgery.
The report also has a position to defend. Fitzgerald uses explicitly colonial hierarchies in arguing for the hospital's value and draws patient experiences into that argument.[2, p32] His account should be read as his own perspective, without treating it as the experience of every Māori patient or family.

Why the date is September 1847
The newspaper dated Wednesday, 29 September says the procedures occurred on Monday. The nearest preceding Monday was 27 September, the date used by the museum. Yet the inpatient table records 28 September in Hiangarere's admission column, while a National Library biographical record gives 20 September, attributing its information to a personal communication in 1998.[1–4]
Admission and operation are different fields. The available records do not explain their sequence here, and changing 28 to 27 would silently alter a source. This article is therefore filed as 1847-09, retaining the inference of 27 September and the other dates in the text. The newspaper claimed a first for the settlement; it does not by itself establish priority throughout New Zealand.
The same report says that Marriott constructed his apparatus from descriptions in English newspapers. The precise design drawings, operative record and original apparatus are not covered here. The illustrations consequently do not manufacture an authoritative-looking inhaler.[1]
Reading another account from the same year
The library's veterinary article preserves a different observation from 1847: a horse's slight limb movement appeared alongside the reporter's judgement that an operation produced no manifestation of pain.[5, p148] The Wellington report instead records the waning of ether's effect and the decision not to apply it again.
The subjects and circumstances differ, but both accounts ask us to distinguish observed responses, contemporary judgements and later summaries. This is a comparison between texts, not evidence that Marriott read the veterinary journal or that human and animal pain can simply be equated.

Hiangarere's name need not appear only beside a claim of priority. The newspaper, inpatient return and letter give the history a longer span: an attempt, a change during surgery, discharge and news after returning home. Keeping that sequence preserves more of the available experience than compressing it into a single successful moment.
Sources and reading limits
- First Trial of the Inhalation of Sulphuric Ether in Port Nicholson. New Zealand Spectator and Cook's Strait Guardian. 29 September 1847;IV(226):2. Original newspaper, Papers Past. Read: the complete report. Not covered: the rest of the issue.
- Fitzgerald J. Medical, report dated 21 January 1848, with letters and inpatient return. New Zealand Government Gazette (Province of New Munster). 2 February 1848;I(7):31–33 and following inpatient table. Original Gazette scan. Read: the issue heading, printed pp. 31–33 and Hiangarere's entry in the inpatient table. The letter is interpreted through the contemporary printed English translation, without manuscript access or an independent linguistic review.
- Geoffrey Kaye Museum. Australia and New Zealand. Relevant 1847 passage read, accessed 30 October 2026. Its compressed accounts of painless removal and extraction are not adopted as the full contemporary sequence.
- National Library of New Zealand. Marriott, James Henry, 1799?–1886, biographical record. Biographical information, the date 20 September 1847 and attribution to Newson's personal communication of 12 February 1998 were read. Not covered: the original communication.
- Ed. Vet. Additional Observations on the Effects of the Inhalation of Æther on Animals. The Veterinarian. 1847;20(231):145–149, specific comparison at p148. Internet Archive. Read: p. 148.
All four images are modern editorial works; the sources are not presented as current clinical guidance.
Continue exploring
Related reading connects shared questions and contexts; it does not by itself establish historical influence.
- 1847: A Horse and a Sheep in the Ether Reports
- 1847: Atherstone Amputates a Thigh Under Ether in Grahamstown
Anesthesia Epochs · The Source Room · About & Editorial Method
Updated October 30, 2026. Sources and reading limits are stated above. Illustrations are labelled as original source images or AI-made. Historical accounts are educational; they are not current treatment instructions.