Tradition says Erdmann and 8 colleagues founded a society in 1905; the journals of the day record a conference of interne anesthetists and an organization in January 1906.
Reading Library · Anesthesia Epochs · 中文版
Watch the education video (for clinicians)
1905: Long Island Society of Anesthetists — Teaching the Incoming · Anesthesia Epochs Education Series

When the American Society of Anesthesiologists traces its origins, the story usually goes like this. In 1905 Dr Adolph Frederick Erdmann, noting that a few physicians in the area practised anesthesia and that "these men ought to get together to form a society", founded the Long Island Society of Anesthetists with 8 colleagues; it was renamed the New York Society of Anesthetists in 1911, the American Society of Anesthetists in 1936, and the American Society of Anesthesiologists in 1945. [5, p. 33]
The story is widely repeated, but its source could not be traced in the material available for this article. What can be read are news notes and an editorial in the Brooklyn medical journals of the time. They describe what happened in more detail, and somewhat differently.
19 December 1905: a conference about internes
The Brooklyn Medical Journal for February 1906 reported that on 19 December 1905 the first meeting of the interne anesthetists of Greater New York took place at the Long Island College Hospital. [1, p. 82] It was "in the nature of a conference": invitations had gone to every hospital in all the boroughs to send its present interne anesthetist and, if possible, the interne who would succeed to the post. Personal invitations went to Dr Buist of the Brooklyn Hospital, Dr Hotchkiss of St John's, Dr Langstreet of the Norwegian, Dr Woolsey of the Bushwick, Dr Neilsen of St Christopher's and Dr Erdman (so spelled) of the Long Island College Hospital. [1, p. 82] Dr J. T. Gwathmey demonstrated the new vapor inhaler already shown at the recent Portland meeting. [1, p. 82]
The point of the note was not a new society but the internes. Anesthetics in the hospitals were largely given by rotating internes, and the note was blunt: most internes serving as anesthetists became careless, and when admonished took it as a personal affront; surgical shock and post-operative pneumonia were sometimes directly correlated with careless administration. [1, p. 82] It asked the visiting surgeons to co-operate with the visiting anesthetists in getting internes to attend, and remarked that the art of anesthesia had "developed wonderfully in the past five years". [1, p. 82] The next conference was to be at the Bushwick Hospital, at Dr Woolsey's invitation. [1, p. 82]
29 January 1906: an executive council
The March 1906 issue reported that the January conference of hospital anesthetists was held on 29 January at the Bushwick Hospital, with representatives from nine hospitals: the Bushwick, Cumberland Street, Long Island College, Jamaica, Nassau, Norwegian, St Catherine's, St John's and Seney. [2, p. 123] The first part of the evening went to a free discussion of the difficulties of the interne anesthetist's position. The main business was "to perfect an organization": the visiting anesthetists were invited to form an executive council, with William C. Woolsey as chairman and Adolf Erdmann as secretary; membership qualifications and future meeting dates were left to committees, and the next meeting was set for the Seney Hospital in March. [2, p. 123]

A year later the new Long Island Medical Journal ran an editorial headed "The Long Island Society of Anesthetists". The society, it said, had been organized in January 1906 by the visiting anesthetists of the Brooklyn hospitals, with Woolsey elected president and Erdmann secretary. [3, p. 87] It met every three months at one of the hospitals, discussed the various phases of anesthesia, and held clinics demonstrating apparatus and new anesthetics; usually internes from six or eight hospitals attended. [3, p. 87–88] In the editor's view much had already been done to systematize the methods of anesthesia in the hospitals and to impress on young internes the importance of careful administration. [3, p. 88]

The same editorial noted that most Long Island surgeons would name ether as the safest and most used anesthetic, which it called "a deplorable fact", and said the society was trying to educate the profession to choose the best anesthetic for each case. [3, p. 88] The volume carried a group of "papers by members of the Long Island Society of Anesthetists", among them Woolsey on the selection of a general anesthetic; Erdmann signed as "Instructor in Anesthesia at the Long Island College Hospital". [3, p. 67; 3, p. 78]
1911: giving up the name
In 1911 the Long Island Medical Journal wrote that for five years, from 1906 to 1911, Long Island could have boasted of the only organized society of anesthetists in America. [4, p. 499] On Saturday 28 October 1911 the society surrendered its name "for the good of the cause" to become the New York Society of Anesthetists. The meeting was a dinner at 40 East 41st Street, with Professor Verworn of Bonn among the guests, who afterwards gave the Harvey Society lecture on narcosis. [4, p. 499–500]

What the record shows
The traditional "1905, Erdmann and 8 colleagues" corresponds in the contemporary journals to a conference called by hospital anesthetists for the internes who gave most anesthetics, and to an executive council formed in January 1906, with Woolsey's name beside Erdmann's. What the organization first worried about was concrete: careless rotating internes, the shock and pneumonia that followed, and the lack of common methods between hospitals. A professional society grew out of problems on the wards.
Sources and reading limits
Read: the Brooklyn Medical Journal vol. 20 (1906), news notes in the February issue, p. 82, and the March issue, p. 123; the Long Island Medical Journal vol. 1 (1907), editorial pp. 87–88 and the members' papers in the same volume; the Long Island Medical Journal vol. 5 (1911), pp. 499–500 on the New York Society of Anesthetists; the Australian Society of Anaesthetists' Anaesthesia History Timeline (2024), p. 33.
Not covered: a Wood Library-Museum timeline entry said to give "6 October 1905" and "nine"; Bacon et al.'s 2005 centenary history of the ASA; Bause's "Four Metamorphoses". No source read gives that date or the number nine. The ASA timeline gives only "1905", "Erdmann ... and 8 colleagues" and Erdmann's remark, without a source. The sources read do not name Gwathmey, Paul Wood, Seifert, Bogart or Cochrane as founders; Gwathmey appears only as the demonstrator of an inhaler at the December 1905 meeting. The 1936 and 1945 renamings are taken from the ASA timeline and were not checked against primary records.
Of the four illustrations, two are crops of the original pages and two are diagrams drawn for this article from the sources, with names taken from them.
- [News notes: first meeting of the interne anesthetists of Greater New York]. Brooklyn Med J. 1906 Feb;20(2):82. Internet Archive
- [News notes: January conference of hospital anesthetists]. Brooklyn Med J. 1906 Mar;20(3):123. Internet Archive
- The Long Island Society of Anesthetists [editorial]. Long Island Med J. 1907;1(2):87-8. Internet Archive
- The New York Society of Anesthetists. Long Island Med J. 1911;5:499-500. Internet Archive
- Australian Society of Anaesthetists. Anaesthesia History Timeline. 2024. p. 33. PDF
Continue exploring
Related reading connects shared questions and contexts; it does not by itself establish historical influence.
- 1893: London's Society of Anaesthetists Brings Experience Before Peers
- 1897: Mary Botsford Builds a Network of Anesthesia Teaching
Anesthesia Epochs · The Source Room · About & Editorial Method
Published November 2, 2026. Sources and reading limits are stated above. Illustrations are labelled as original source images or AI-made. Historical accounts are educational; they are not current treatment instructions.
