Claude Bernard showed in dogs in 1869 that morphine followed by chloroform gave anaesthesia with less chloroform, and in 1872 Labbé and Guyon reported four operations under the combination.
Reading Library · Anesthesia Epochs · 中文版
Watch the education video (for clinicians)
1869–1872: Morphine and Chloroform — Bernard, Labbé and Guyon · Anesthesia Epochs Education Series

Two modern editorial booklets marked 1869 and 1872 locate the documents in time. This original still life does not reproduce either historical cover.
On 27 January 1872, a young man at the Pitié Hospital in Paris underwent an amputation above the ankle. The report described morphine before the operation, followed by chloroform; surgery lasted seventeen minutes. Later, while sensation had not yet returned, the patient answered every question and was described as quite alert. [2, p. 628]
The account separated several things that a shorter history might merge: answering questions, having sensation, undergoing an operation and remaining under a drug’s influence. Combining two drugs did not make these a single outcome.
This history begins with a lecture extract published under Claude Bernard’s name in 1869 and proceeds to four cases presented to the Academy of Sciences on 26 February 1872. The dates identify stages in publication and reporting, without deciding worldwide priority.
Motionless did not mean unresponsive
Bernard’s article opened with a dog rendered still after morphine. Yet stimulation could still produce movement or cries, and noise could provoke marked responses. Bernard did not simply equate immobility with the loss of sensation Bernard attributed to chloroform. [1, pp. 241–242]
Bernard then recalled an observation about five years earlier. A dog recovering from chloroform became insensible again after morphine. This was a retrospective account in an 1869 publication; its relative dating is retained without inventing a precise discovery day. [1, p. 243]
Bernard also reversed the order. Morphine followed by chloroform produced, in Bernard’s account, rapid insensibility that could be maintained with less chloroform. Under that sequence, sensation could return quickly when chloroform was stopped. The two orders were not described as identical processes. [1, pp. 244, 247–250]

Two differently colored fabric ribbons partly overlap while remaining distinguishable. This modern metaphor represents overlapping effects, not mixing proportions, nerve pathways or an administration sequence.
Explanation carried its own uncertainties
Bernard reasoned in terms of superimposed effects, residual chloroform in the blood and changes in nervous susceptibility. Bernard repeatedly noticed differences between animals. The closing discussion emphasized absorption and the purity of substances as conditions for comparable observations. [1, pp. 246–256]
These pages preserve Bernard’s theoretical work. They do not establish a modern receptor mechanism, and the language of superposition should not silently become a present-day pharmacodynamic conclusion.
Page 245 proposed a surgical application: morphine first, followed by less chloroform. Bernard hoped to diminish excitement and the dangers associated with larger amounts of chloroform. On the same page, however, Bernard warned against transferring animal doses directly to people and described serious consequences of excessive administration. [1, p. 245] This was a proposal informed by judgment and expectation, not a safety finding from a comparison of clinical outcomes.
Four patients entered the report
The 1872 paper explicitly referred to Bernard’s demonstrations at the Collège de France before turning to its authors’ clinical observations. The inspected heading names L. Labbé and E. Guyon, with Cl. Bernard presenting the note. [2, p. 627]
Each case had its own operation and course. Two were dated 27 January: the amputation above the ankle and an operation to remove tissue from the greater trochanter, lasting seventeen and thirty-two minutes respectively. The third concerned an anal fistula operation on 30 January. The fourth described an ovariotomy in a twenty-year-old woman, lasting one hour and forty-five minutes; that paragraph did not supply a separate operation date. [2, pp. 628–629]
All four descriptions recorded an excitation period, with differences in degree or duration. The paper therefore cannot be summarized as showing that the combination eliminated excitement. The fourth patient was reported to awaken calmly, saying that nothing had been felt and that there was still no pain. The first case placed alert answers beside sensation that had not yet returned. These were several observations within a small series.

Four equal blank cards represent the four reported observations. They are not original case records, four trial groups or an efficacy chart.
Amount expended was not amount absorbed
Before presenting the cases, the authors called their report a short summary. They intended to develop the work and measure the amount of chloroform actually absorbed more precisely. [2, p. 628]
The quantities subsequently listed as expended cannot therefore be treated as precise measurements of absorbed dose. This mattered to comparison: the amount used from a container, the amount entering the body and the patient’s response were distinct quantities or observations.
On the final page, the authors acknowledged that their research was very incomplete. They nevertheless concluded that anesthesia could be obtained faster, last longer and be maintained with small amounts of chloroform. They extended this to the possibility of considerably fewer fatal accidents. [2, p. 629]
The four narratives supplied no concurrent control, common long-term follow-up or evidence adequate to estimate rare fatal events. They document how the authors described their patients; they do not demonstrate a reduction in mortality. Suggestions for further changes in administration remain historical proposals, not a regimen reproduced for current use.

An ordinary balance with empty pans and a closed unmarked notebook represents the unresolved measurement problem. It is not an apparatus for measuring inhaled dose or a reconstruction of hospital equipment.
A process, not a single year
The 1869 account itself recalled earlier events, and the 1872 note mentioned other clinicians’ prior attempts. Together they preserve a continuing process of discussion, use and explanation. They cannot be reduced to a single invention year.
The amputee who could answer questions offers a particular starting point. After two drugs had acted together, clinicians still had to describe responses, the operation, recovery and what they did not know. The number of agents alone could not answer those questions.
Sources and reading limits
Read: Bernard’s article in the Bulletin général de thérapeutique of 1869 (pp. 241–256), an extract from lectures at the Collège de France; the note by Labbé and Guyon, presented by Bernard to the Académie des sciences on 26 February 1872 (pp. 627–629).
Not covered: the first publication of the lectures in the Revue des Cours scientifiques; manuscripts and hospital case books; the papers of earlier workers the note cites, such as Nussbaum. Priority, the origin of balanced anaesthesia and modern mechanisms are not judged here. The four illustrations are AI-made interpretive images, not historical evidence.
- Bernard C. Des effets physiologiques de la morphine et de leur combinaison avec ceux du chloroforme. Bull Gen Ther Med Chir. 1869;77:241–56. Internet Archive
- Labbé L, Guyon E. Sur l’action combinée de la morphine et du chloroforme. C R Acad Sci. 1872;74:627–9. Internet Archive
Continue exploring
Related reading connects shared questions and contexts; it does not by itself establish historical influence.
- 1848: Snow Warns That Chloroform Keeps Deepening After Inhalation
- 1864: The Chloroform Committee Report and a Changing Vapour
- 1869: Liebreich and Chloral Hydrate
Anesthesia Epochs · The Source Room · About & Editorial Method
Updated October 30, 2026. Sources and reading limits are stated above. Illustrations are labelled as original source images or AI-made. Historical accounts are educational; they are not current treatment instructions.