In 1888–1889 Sydney journals recorded a hospital chloroformist’s appointment, a debate over who answered for anaesthesia and how students should learn it, and R. H. Todd listed as anaesthetist at Prince Alfred Hospital.
Reading Library · Anesthesia Epochs · 中文版
Watch the education video (for clinicians)
1888–1889: Anaesthetic Roles in Sydney — A Post With No Settled Duties · Anesthesia Epochs Education Series
In April 1888, the appointments column of the Australasian Medical Gazette carried a brief notice: George Childs Macdonald had been appointed Chloroformist at St Vincent's Hospital, Sydney. It listed a name, qualifications and a position, without an accompanying professional manifesto. [1, p. 181]
The notice places a named anaesthetic role among hospital appointments. It does not establish acceptance, a starting date, length of service, or full-time salaried employment. Other pages from the same year reveal more about what such a role might mean. Doctors were debating who should bear responsibility for anaesthesia and how students should learn it.
A position needed responsibilities
On 3 August 1888, the New South Wales Branch of the British Medical Association met in the Royal Society's rooms in Sydney. A paper by Samuel T. Knaggs on anaesthetic ethics opened a discussion. Both paper and proceedings appeared in the September issue. [1, pp. 296–298, 313–315]
Knaggs argued that operator and administrator should participate in consultation before an operation, considering the patient's condition and the proposed procedure. The administrator should have a voice before the task was handed over. Knaggs also argued that, if dangerous signs arose during an operation, the administrator should be able to veto its further progress. [1, p. 297]
This was a proposed professional arrangement, not an established uniform rule. The discussion shows how little agreement there was about dividing responsibility.
Chambers, the president, favored appointing hospital chloroformists who would both administer anaesthetics and teach students. Chambers doubted, however, whether participation in the earlier consultation was always practicable. Shewen rejected an equal division of responsibility for administration: once the patient was in the administrator's care, that responsibility should rest with the administrator. [1, p. 313]
Hankins introduced a distinction between hospital practice involving a student and private practice in which the operator selected a trusted colleague. Scot-Skirving distinguished shared judgment before anaesthesia from responsibility after administration had begun. [1, p. 314]
The record preserves disagreement. Hospital staffing, private collaboration, students and the transfer of a patient's care each changed how participants understood the role.
Someone to administer—and someone to teach
Training ran through the debate. Knaggs proposed that learners first observe an experienced practitioner and then administer under supervision. Chambers questioned how much instruction students received. Shewen disputed the suggestion that teaching at Prince Alfred Hospital was inadequate; Scot-Skirving challenged that reassurance in turn. [1, pp. 298, 313–314]
One passage is particularly vulnerable to being quoted alone. Near the end of the paper, Knaggs explicitly adopted an opposing position for the sake of argument: all medical practitioners needed to learn anaesthesia. In the reply, Knaggs explicitly explained approving of experts serving as administrators and instructors. The apparent opposition had been intended to draw definite opinions from the speakers. [1, pp. 298, 314]
Extracting the objection without its stated purpose and the subsequent reply could therefore turn Knaggs into an opponent of specialization. Read together, they raise a more practical question: could a designated practitioner provide a service and teach others, while preserving opportunities to learn?
Experience was not accepted by everyone as a guarantee of safety. Answering an optimistic claim about experienced chloroformists, Knaggs referred to six Sydney deaths of the previous four years, examined at autopsy, in which every reasonable care had been used. The account supplied neither a complete denominator nor a comparison group. It does show a challenge to confidence based on experience alone. [1, p. 314]
The speakers also discussed death inquiries, support for colleagues and protection of the profession. Their arguments should retain that setting, rather than becoming a story concerned solely with ideas now associated with patient safety. [1, pp. 314–315]
A professional announcement at year's end
The December issue carried news of Robert H. Todd. Todd had given up general practice and had determined to work at administering anaesthetics for the profession, moving from Waverley to Queen Anne Chambers in Bond Street, Sydney. [2, p. 79]
Specialized work appeared here as an announced direction of practice, as well as in a hospital appointment column. The paragraph does not establish a later university teaching appointment or show that Todd's subsequent career never changed course.
Its date requires care. The bound volume's title page bears 1889; the page itself belongs to December 1888. Those three records remain dated to 1888. The 1889 material below has its own contemporary evidence. This article spans 1888–1889 without using a binding date to redate a notice or inventing one shared date on which a specialty began.
What the 1889 roster actually called the role
The University of Sydney's Calendar for 1889 supplies a different kind of record. Its Prince Alfred Hospital roster lists R. H. Todd as “Anæsthetist.” On the same page, the “Medical Tutor” is Edward J. Jenkins. [5, p. 183]
The preceding page explains the institutional arrangement. The hospital provided clinical education for university students. Its medical officers were appointed by a conjoint board of the University Senate and the hospital directors, which also regulated students' access and studies. This places Todd in a hospital linked to the university; it does not by itself turn the printed title into “University Tutor in Anaesthetics.” [5, pp. [182]–183]
Nor does the roster prove that Todd had no other appointment or teaching duties. It establishes how these positions were listed. A first university anaesthetic tutorship could not be confirmed in the sources read; it would need its own appointment evidence. The pages do not supply an exact starting date, salary or complete tenure.
Todd also continued to participate in professional discussion. Proceedings published in August record that Todd presented a paper comparing methods of treating accidents of general anaesthesia at the branch meeting on 5 July. Colleagues commented, and Todd replied. These are minutes of the discussion, not the full paper. [2, pp. 292–293]
The September issue reported another change: Todd, formerly of College Street, Sydney, and H. H. Orr had taken over a practice at Maclean. The appointments column in the same issue listed Robert Henry Todd as Government Medical Officer and Vaccinator for the Lower Clarence River district. [2, pp. 339, 341] These notices do not date each step precisely. They do caution against turning Todd’s 1888 declaration of specialized practice into a claim about the rest of that career.
These records from 1888–1889 turn a job title into several contested duties: assessing risk, attending to the patient, supervising beginners and explaining what happened when a patient died. A position could appear in a short notice while its boundaries remained matters for debate.
Sources and reading limits
Read: the April 1888 appointments page, Knaggs’s paper and the complete 3 August 1888 discussion in the Australasian Medical Gazette, vol. VII; the December 1888, August 1889 and September 1889 pages of vol. VIII cited below; the title page and Prince Alfred Hospital section of the University of Sydney Calendar for 1889; one page of the 2004 ANZCA Bulletin; and one bibliography page of Wilson’s One Grand Chain. The hospital description page in the Calendar has no printed number and is cited as [182], preceding the numbered page 183. Separate sections in one journal are not independent corroborations.
An 1888 St Vincent's appointment of Joseph Labatt De Lambert could not be confirmed in the sources read. A historical aside in an ANZCA article from 2004 names Charles de Lambert and says priority relative to Geoffrey Frederick Travers in Melbourne remains uncertain because documentation is lacking. [3] The contemporary April notice located for this article names Macdonald. Hospital records, acceptance, actual tenure and the relationships among these names remain unverified. Macdonald is not therefore declared Australia's first, nor is the published appointment treated as proof that Macdonald served.
Not covered: the complete journal volumes and the rest of the Calendar; Todd’s complete 1889 paper; hospital archives; the narrative volume of Wilson’s One Grand Chain and the Bailey article it cites. Wilson’s bibliography helped locate the journal material; a reference list is not the text it cites. [4] Todd’s 1889 hospital roster entry is verified; claims about a particular university tutorship, De Lambert’s identity and tenure, and wider priority claims remain unverified.
- The Australasian Medical Gazette. Vol VII, October 1887–September 1888. Sydney: L. Bruck; 1888. April, p. 181, appointments; Knaggs ST, Ethics in the Administration of Anæsthetics, September, pp. 296–298; NSW Branch proceedings for 3 August, published September, pp. 313–315. Original volume.
- The Australasian Medical Gazette. Vol VIII, October 1888–September 1889. Sydney: L. Bruck; 1889. December 1888, p. 79, Todd notice; August 1889, pp. 292–293, proceedings for 5 July; September, pp. 339, 341, practice and appointment notices. Original volume.
- Loughnan T. Lennard Gilmore Travers MBE. ANZCA Bulletin. August 2004:21. Available from: ANZCA repository.
- Wilson G. One Grand Chain, Vol 1, Book of References, p. 14. Available from: ANZCA repository.
- Calendar of the University of Sydney for the Year 1889. Sydney: Gibbs, Shallard & Co.; 1889. Title and hospital section, pp. [182]–183. University of Sydney Archives, REF-00020859. Available from: University of Sydney Archives.
Continue exploring
Related reading connects shared questions and contexts; it does not by itself establish historical influence.
Anesthesia Epochs · The Source Room · About & Editorial Method
Updated October 30, 2026. Sources and reading limits are stated above. Illustrations are labelled as original source images or AI-made. Historical accounts are educational; they are not current treatment instructions.
