In Bordeaux in February 1874, Oré gave chloral hydrate into a vein to a man with tetanus and removed the nail of an injured finger without a complaint, while the outcome of the tetanus was left to be reported later.
Reading Library · Anesthesia Epochs · 中文版
Watch the education video (for clinicians)
1874: Oré's Intravenous Chloral — One Case, Two Questions · Anesthesia Epochs Education Series

An original imagining of an 1870s hospital room: an empty bed, a chair and window light. It does not reconstruct an identified room at Saint-André or depict an authenticated procedure scene.
A fifty-two-year-old man developed tetanus after an injury to the left middle finger. According to Oré’s report, slight pressure on the fingertip intensified rigidity and caused intolerable pain. At the Saint-André Hospital in Bordeaux, Oré decided to give chloral hydrate intravenously. [1, pp. 515–516]
The text supplied a specific time: about five in the afternoon on 9 February. After the second injection, the patient entered a quiet sleep and muscular rigidity almost disappeared. The previously painful finger could be examined; Oré then removed the nail and attended to the wound. [1, p. 516]
Two questions now occupied the same case. Could the induced state permit an operation? What would happen to the patient’s tetanus? The preliminary report of 16 February did not answer them in the same way.
A claim from animals met a particular patient
The Academy note was headed “De l’anesthésie produite chez l’homme par les injections de chloral dans les veines,” attributed to Oré and presented by Bouillaud. It began by quoting a communication the author had sent to the Paris surgical society on 29 May 1872. That passage recalled animal experiments and made strong claims for the advantages of intravenous chloral. [1, p. 515]
Oré then offered the human case as a test of whether the animal experience could be transferred. Two levels of evidence need to remain visible: Oré’s assessment of previous work, and what this particular report recorded. The cited 1872 original and complete animal data are not covered here. The self-quotation cannot automatically become a verified finding of superiority to chloroform.
This was an account of one patient, not a concurrent comparison of two anesthetic methods.

Modern editorial cards distinguish 1874-02-09 from 1874-02-16: the procedure date in the account and the Academy session date. They are not facsimiles of a casebook or letter.
Changes before and after administration
On admission, the patient had marked trismus and neck rigidity. Attempts to move, speak or swallow could provoke widespread muscular contractions, accompanied by respiratory and circulatory disturbance. The patient’s intellectual faculties were described as intact. [1, p. 516]
Oré recorded two injections into one of the right radial veins on 9 February. Oré then described quiet sleep, calmer and more regular breathing, the near disappearance of muscular rigidity and improved opening of the jaws. Touch and movement of the limbs no longer elicited the previous reflex convulsions. [1, p. 516]
These were the author’s observations during the period described. Calm breathing is not substituted for continuous monitoring, and a completed procedure does not establish safety. The historical quantities and preparation remain in the source; they are not reproduced here as a modern administration method.
During removal of the nail and treatment of the wound, Oré reported neither a complaint nor movement. [1, pp. 516–517] This supports Oré’s account that the particular procedure could be performed. It supplies neither the patient’s recollection nor the evidence required for a present-day assessment of awareness and memory. A procedure on a finger should also not become an undocumented major operation in retelling.
Sleep continued, and recovery needed observation
At nine that evening, Oré examined the patient again and described deep sleep without an evident response to pinching or touch. The report placed awakening at four the next morning. Oré next saw the patient at nine, when sensation had returned but was still incomplete, especially in the lower limbs. [1, p. 517]
Those times cannot be compressed into an awakening at nine in the morning. Nor can the entire period of sleep automatically be treated as continuously measured surgical anesthesia. Sleep, responses to stimulation and recovery of sensation appeared in neighboring paragraphs, but they remain distinct observations.

An ordinary closed pocket watch beside blank paper represents repeated observation. No dial or duration is shown. It is not an object used by Oré or evidence of a measured anesthetic duration.
Further administrations and observations were recorded on 10 and 11 February. These continued the same patient’s history; they were not three independent successful cases. [1, p. 517]
One answer remained open at the end
The closing paragraph explicitly deferred discussion of the injections’ effect on the tetanus itself. Oré intended to publish the observation when the outcome was known. At that point, Oré reported only that the patient had reached the eleventh day of illness and that the tetanus appeared considerably improved. [1, p. 517]
A retelling that makes this preliminary note establish both successful intravenous anesthesia and a cure of tetanus exceeds the boundary the author supplied. Later outcome reports are not covered here. That defines the endpoint of the present account; it does not imply that no follow-up was ever published.

A partly open blank notebook with a fabric bookmark represents a record awaiting continuation. This original still life neither reproduces nor invents clinical data.
Keeping this case in proportion
Oré’s 1874 preliminary note preserves one patient with tetanus, a procedure on an injured finger, and observations extending over several days.
The original supplies a specific basis for 9 February as the procedure date while preserving 16 February as the report date. This one case does not adjudicate global priority, general clinical suitability or superiority to other methods.
A change in pain responses and rigidity permitted attention to the damaged nail. Whether that procedure could be completed, and how the disease would end, were still separate questions.
Sources and reading limits
Read: Oré’s note “De l’anesthésie produite chez l’homme par les injections de chloral dans les veines”, presented by Bouillaud to the Académie des sciences on 16 February 1874 (Comptes rendus, vol. 78, pp. 515–517), in full.
Not covered: the hospital case book; Oré’s 1872 communication to the Société de chirurgie; later reports of the outcome; the 1875 monograph. The clock times and the stated length of sleep for 10 February do not fully agree in the note; that length is not adopted or silently corrected. The absence of pain behaviour is not equated with a modern assessment of awareness, and priority, cure and safety are not established. The four illustrations are AI-made interpretive images, not historical evidence.
- Oré PC. De l’anesthésie produite chez l’homme par les injections de chloral dans les veines. C R Acad Sci. 1874;78:515–7. Internet Archive
Continue exploring
Related reading connects shared questions and contexts; it does not by itself establish historical influence.
- 1656: Wren Opens a Route into the Blood
- 1869: Liebreich and Chloral Hydrate
- 1934: Lundy Uses and Observes Thiopental at the Mayo Clinic
Anesthesia Epochs · The Source Room · About & Editorial Method
Updated October 30, 2026. Sources and reading limits are stated above. Illustrations are labelled as original source images or AI-made. Historical accounts are educational; they are not current treatment instructions.