
A sixteenth-century BCE medical compilation records therapeutic intentions, not proof of poppy anesthesia

In Regimen II the poppy is a nourishing seed; a 1998 study concluded that its power against pain was not yet recognised.

In De materia medica 4.75, Dioscorides reports that some people prepare mandragora root in wine for those about to be cut or cauterized, while warning that a larger amount of the juice can kill.

In De medicina 5.25, Celsus calls pills that relieve pain through sleep anodyna, but says they should be used only under strong necessity, because their ingredients are powerful and bad for the stomach.

Two histories, the Records of the Three Kingdoms and the History of the Later Han, say that Hua Tuo's patients drank mafeisan and lost awareness before surgery, but neither records its ingredients, a dated operation or a checkable outcome.

A 1907 English translation of the Sushruta Samhita advises giving strong wine before an operation, if the patient is used to it, so that pain is not felt; the passage is a textual instruction, not a record of a first anesthetic.

Recipes for a soporific sponge or drink, a tradition that surgical texts carry into the thirteenth century, promise sleep through an operation, but the surviving texts record prescriptions and routes, not patients or outcomes.

In Paracelsus' writings the word laudanum could name ladanum resin or a compound remedy containing pearls, so, as Sigerist showed in 1941, it cannot simply be read as the later opium tincture.

Valerius Cordus's account of preparing sweet oil of vitriol, later read as ether, is conventionally dated to about 1540, but the version that can be inspected was printed after his death, in Strasbourg in 1561.

Ralegh's 1596 Discoverie of Guiana describes arrow poison causing torment and madness, with a cure kept by priests; the symptoms do not match curare's quiet paralysis.

Garcilasso's Royal Commentaries of 1609 preserve Blas Valera's note that doctors applied pounded coca to sores and broken bones; it mentions no pain or surgery, so an Inca local anaesthetic is a modern inference.

A recipe for a drink 'to cause a man to sleepe till hee bee ript' survives in Jane Jackson's handwritten book dated 1642, showing that a medieval recipe tradition was still being copied, though the book records no patient who took it.

In Oxford around 1656, Christopher Wren helped inject opium dissolved in wine into a dog's vein; Boyle's 1663 account describes deep stupor and recovery, which opened a route into the blood but did not yet amount to a surgical anesthetic.

In 1664 the Hamburg physician Johann Daniel Major published a short Latin book proposing to infuse medicines into a vein; he called it a conjecture awaiting experiments, and the claim of a successful operation in 1662 remains unverified.

Frobenius's paper in the Philosophical Transactions described a cold, volatile, flammable liquid that dissolved fats, the ethereal spirit of wine, but left out the full recipe.

La Condamine told the Académie des Sciences of a blowpipe dart poison that killed within a minute yet left game safe to eat, and tested it on hens.

In a letter read to the Royal Society in 1763, Edward Stone reported giving willow bark to about fifty people with agues, noting the stubborn cases in which he added Peruvian bark.

In experiments reported between 1772 and 1774, Priestley turned nitrous air (nitric oxide) into a new gas, later identified as nitrous oxide, that kept a candle burning but did not sustain an animal; he imagined medical uses but described no anaesthesia.

From a dedicated hospital proposal to working correspondence

1800: temporary relief of tooth pain and a surgical proposal still to be tested

Crystals, a provisional name and medicinal action still to be compared

1804: tumor excision under Mafutsusan, followed through a transmitted case record

Botanical kinship, a comparison experiment and unresolved analysis

Brodie kept a cat poisoned with woorara alive by inflating its lungs for three hours; in 1825 Waterton kept a poisoned she-ass alive with bellows.

Sertürner of Einbeck called opium's active principle a salt-forming base, and recorded that Sertürner and three youths nearly fainted after taking it.

A note in the Royal Institution's journal said inhaled ether vapour acts much like nitrous oxide, and that one man stayed lethargic for thirty hours.

1824: six experimental summaries, a bold analogy, and the author's own reservation

Dating an exchange, a preface and a publication

Guthrie of Sackett's Harbor distilled chloride of lime with alcohol to make a sweet chloric ether, freely drunk in the laboratory; the journal's editor sent it to physicians.

Two comparisons, a clue in the liquid, and a conditional hope

A brief report and the uncertainty retained in a longer paper

Changes in storage, transformations under acid, and the limits of comparison

A country doctor slipped morphine under the skin with a vaccination lancet to treat neuralgia; the Academy's reporter repeated the tests and warned against half-proofs.

Distinguishing products, recording analyses and retaining open questions

In 1881 Lyman wrote that student William E. Clarke gave ether on a towel while a dentist drew a tooth; Buxton in 1925 called it 'said to have been performed'.

One patient, two operations in 1842, and a publication delayed until 1849

Two cases and different evidence of follow-up

Colton gave the gas, Riggs removed the tooth, and Wells supplied the pain report

Observed behavior, reported pain and the audience's verdict were not interchangeable

Fisher's attempt with ether on a patient of Jobert's in Paris failed in December 1846; five weeks later a Boston inhaler brought success at the Hôtel-Dieu.

On 30 September 1846 Morton gave Eben Frost a preparation on a handkerchief; Frost woke to find the tooth out and signed a certificate with two witnesses that night.

From public demonstration to a written claim

Public cases, differing pain accounts and further experiments in 1846

After deaths at Colchester and Grantham and an inquest blaming the vapour, the journal called for statistical evidence on whether ether raised operative mortality.

In dogs, Flourens found ether abolished brain function, then spinal sensation and movement, while the medulla held out last; Flourens also tried chloroform.

Pirogoff wrote from St Petersburg to the Paris Academy proposing rectal ether vapour for surgery, while animal reports that year disagreed about its safety.

The Edinburgh dentist Imlach gave chloroform on a handkerchief with a gag placed beforehand, and in 1848 reported more than three hundred extractions.

After trying other devices, Sédillot's Strasbourg clinic adopted a chloroform inhaler by the instrument maker Elser that covered both mouth and nose.

An 1847 Boston pamphlet under Morton's name advised letting the labouring woman hold the ether sponge herself, since her raised hand drops once enough is inhaled.

Tracy gave ether and Skey operated; the child lived and the mother died; the Lancet said the ether never took full effect, while a French summary made it sound painless.
