
Hu Houxuan read acupuncture into three oracle-bone glyphs; in 2001 Li Zong-kun found the claims, including a story of painless tooth extraction, unconvincing.

A sixteenth-century BCE medical compilation records therapeutic intentions, not proof of poppy anesthesia

In Regimen II the poppy is a nourishing seed; a 1998 study concluded that its power against pain was not yet recognised.

In De medicina 5.25, Celsus calls pills that relieve pain through sleep anodyna, but says they should be used only under strong necessity, because their ingredients are powerful and bad for the stomach.

In Book One of the Canon, written before 1015, Avicenna lists snow and ice-cold water among stupefacient materials, but places them in a discussion that weighs quick relief of pain against the harm it may cause.

Garcilasso's Royal Commentaries of 1609 preserve Blas Valera's note that doctors applied pounded coca to sores and broken bones; it mentions no pain or surgery, so an Inca local anaesthetic is a modern inference.

Moore numbed a limb by pressing on its nerves, tested the method on his own thigh, and watched John Hunter amputate a leg while the patient barely cried out.

A country doctor slipped morphine under the skin with a vaccination lancet to treat neuralgia; the Academy's reporter repeated the tests and warned against half-proofs.

Two cases and different evidence of follow-up

A Bengal civil surgeon tried mesmerism on a convict in pain and reported 73 'painless' operations within eight months; the claims rest on Esdaile's own 1846 book.

Two injection histories meet in 1853, but relief of neuralgia and experimental arterial coagulation were not the same clinical achievement

Abscesses forced Hunter to stop injecting at the painful spot; injections into the arm relieved neuralgia as well, and the 'hypodermic method' was argued into being.

In Wöhler's Göttingen laboratory, Albert Niemann extracted a crystalline base from coca leaves brought on the Novara and named it 'cocain'; it numbed the tongue.

Richardson forced ether through a fine jet with hand bellows to freeze the skin for tooth extraction and incision, inspired by a toy perfume spray.

At the Société de Biologie, small doses of cocaine heightened sensibility in frogs while larger doses abolished it, without wholly abolishing movement.

In Rossbach's Würzburg laboratory, von Anrep injected dilute cocaine under the skin, felt no needle pricks, and recommended testing cocaine as a 'local anaesthetic'.

Within weeks of Koller's cocaine drops, Knapp injected a few minims behind the globe to remove an eye, and warned at once about the orbit's blood supply.

A delegated report in September1884 opened a clinical possibility whose limits remained visible in the cases

An 1884 report separated a filling, sensory experiments and systemic symptoms; later summaries should do the same

Halsted's 1885 cocaine paper never mentions the brachial plexus; the claim that Halsted blocked it reaches us through Matas, quoted in 1958.

The dog and human observations of 1885 do not by themselves establish a modern spinal anesthetic

Pressure measurement, temporary responses and diagnostic possibilities

Samples, animal comparisons and the limits of clinical extrapolation

Frequency, painless passage and brief analgesia under the electrodes

Von Mering found acetyl-p-aminophenol, now called paracetamol, acted promptly against fever and pain, but rejected it for p-aminophenol's side effects and preferred phenacetin.

Two-minute onset, eight-minute duration, and narrowed ophthalmic niches

A Berlin surgeon showed that tissue swollen with very weak cocaine solution could be cut without pain, and argued most operations did not need chloroform.

Chemistry, patents and credit for an analgesic

Six surgical cases, two self-experiments, and the questions preserved in the 1899 report

Tuffier presented operations under subarachnoid cocaine to the Paris surgical society, admitted failures in laparotomy, and started the spread of spinal anaesthesia in Europe.

Kreis of Basel reported six labours under spinal analgesia; two theses record its effect and its drawback, the loss of the reflex urge to bear down.

Takamine described a pure, stable, crystalline principle that blanched the conjunctiva and raised blood pressure, and urged its use against 'collapse in anesthesia'.

Two 1901 communications separated extradural localization, pain relief and operative anesthesia

Reclus told the Académie de médecine that Fourneau's new local analgesic stovaine equalled cocaine in patients, was less toxic and would replace it.

A 1905 report separates a chemical candidate, patent dates and evidence for particular applications

A London surgeon gave repeated stovaine doses through a cannula left in the spine; in 1940 Lemmon of Philadelphia reported about 200 continuous spinals.

Barker reported 100 spinal anaesthetics with stovaine and used glass tubes bent like the spine to show that a heavy solution sinks to the lowest point.

Bier isolated a bloodless limb segment between two rubber bandages and injected dilute novocaine into a vein, so resections and amputations could be done under local anaesthesia.

Stoeckel injected novocaine through the sacral hiatus in 141 labours; colleagues found the relief modest and the effect on contractions worrying.

Hirschel in Heidelberg reached the brachial plexus through the axilla; Kulenkampff in Zwickau went above the clavicle, guided by the subclavian artery, first rib and paraesthesiae.

Perthes used a lacquered needle as the electrode of a weak current; when its tip touched a mixed nerve the muscles twitched, and the anaesthetic went in.

Freund and Speyer of Frankfurt made the compound now called oxycodone; in 1917 Falk reported it as Eukodal for pain and before ether, noting a breathing pause under chloroform.

A 1921 report recorded operations, failures and a serious accident together

Labat's English textbook, with a foreword by William J. Mayo, defined field-block and nerve-block and insisted on anatomy, proper instruments and experience.

A psychologist's paper on rating traits set out the method later borrowed for pain: a check mark anywhere on a straight line between two described extremes.

Histories link caudal analgesia in India with Kokatnur of Belgaum from 1924; Kokatnur's 1944 paper reported not less than 400 cases.

An idea of parting the dural fibres instead of cutting them, carried from office lumbar puncture to spinal anaesthesia

Aburel moved from skin injections and a plexus block to a thread-like catheter passed through a trocar and left in place for repeated doses.

A 1932 eye report separates chemical modifications, clinical observations and unanswered questions about toxicity

The hanging drop sign for the epidural space is credited to Gutiérrez of Buenos Aires; Gutiérrez's papers could not be read, so later theses and reviews tell the story.
